^{This page is part of © FOTW Flags Of The World website}

Philippines: the shade of blue

Five colour changes

The blue colour has changed at least five times in the Philippines flag:

Background
1898-1902: Cuban blue
1919-1981: Navy or American blue
1981-1986: pale sky blue
1986-1998: Navy or American blue
1998 to present: royal blue

See also:

There has been a long-standing debate on the proper shade of blue for the Philippine flag. A good synopsis of the debate has been written by Philippine historian Ambeth Ocampo:

In 1955, the Heraldry Commission issued the official specification for the Philippine flag. The shade of blue given was United States Cable 70077, or navy blue. Earlier, all flags had been using navy blue. However, the late Domingo Abella, the Director of the National Archives and a member of the NHI [National Historical Institute] believed that the shade of blue should be light blue, because he says that at the turn of the century when the Philippine flag was finally allowed to fly and be displayed after years of suppression, flag makers didn't have a supply of light blue cloth. Thus, they used dark-blue cloth instead, perpetuating the mistake. No documentary evidence was presented by Abella and so he was not taken seriously till the late Teodoro A. Agoncillo also supported the camp battling for the light-blue flag. E. Aguilar Cruz, another member of the NHI, stated in his monograph of [Philippine revolutionary and artist] Juan Luna that he found a watercolor by Luna which showed a Philippine flag with a light-blue field. [Aguinaldo's first Prime Minister] Apolinario Mabini in one of his letters even proposed that the blue in the flag of the Revolution be 'azul celeste', or sky blue.

The navy-blue camp is supported by all extant flags having this color, plus the testimony of Marcela Agoncillo, the only surviving daughter of Marcela Agoncillo, who made the original flag which Aguinaldo waved to the crowd outside his mansion in Cavite when he declared Philippine Independence.

However, both sides may be wrong, because in a letter to [sympathizer of the Filipino cause and friend of Jose Rizal] Ferdinand Blumentritt in 1898 [Filipino revolutionary] Mariano Ponce sent a drawing of the Philippine flag which showed that the blue is 'azul oscuro' which is in between 'azul celeste' (sky blue or light blue) and 'azul marino' (navy or dark blue). So the blue in the flag is not sky blue but a shade lighter than the present navy blue. This caused confusion among the people. Someone mistook 'lighter than the present blue' to mean sky blue, which is wrong. The issue would have ended here had Ponce kept quiet because in 1899, in one of the few letters he wrote in English, he told a Mr. Y. Fukishama, "My dear sir, I am sending you, by parcel post, one scarf pin representing our flag: please
accept it as a poor souvenir. The blue color of the sky means our hope in future prosperity through progress".

Noted historian Carmen Guerrero Nakpil asserts that the original color was 'Cuban blue', although this assertion is itself subject to different interpretations since there isn't an official shade for the color blue in the Cuban flag.

To confuse things even further, the late Filipino artist Galo Ocampo (designer of the 1946 coat of arms of the Philippine Republic and for decades head of the Heraldry Authority of the Philippines) wrote to the Minister of Education in 1985, saying that the Heraldry authority adopted the dark blue in 1955 after consultations with General Aguinaldo. It seems the Heraldry Institute (then headed by him) showed the aging Aguinaldo a color chart and asked him to think back of how the original flag looked like Yale Blue.

Critics opposed the sky blue because 'that the color shouldn't be sky blue, as the blue part would merge with the sky and disappear, leaving the flag looking like a misshapen red and white trumpet.'

Manuel L. Quezon III, 12 April 2002